Learning What Matters: Supervising Sparse Attention Routing with Causal Evidence Sets
Mirrored from arXiv — Machine Learning for archival readability. Support the source by reading on the original site.
Computer Science > Machine Learning
arXiv:2607.21692 (cs)
[Submitted on 23 Jul 2026]
Title:Learning What Matters: Supervising Sparse Attention Routing with Causal Evidence Sets
Authors:Jim Allchin
View a PDF of the paper titled Learning What Matters: Supervising Sparse Attention Routing with Causal Evidence Sets, by Jim Allchin
View PDF
HTML (experimental)
Abstract:Sparse attention reduces the cost of long contexts by allowing each query to read only selected parts of the input. These selectors are often trained by distilling the attention patterns of a dense teacher, assuming that attention reveals which context the teacher actually uses. We test that assumption on retrieval tasks where the evidence for each answer is known exactly. By masking parts of the context and measuring whether the answer changes, we find that attention and causal dependence often disagree, and distilled selectors inherit the mismatch. Teachers attend to outdated facts they have learned to ignore, and their attention can vary across training runs even when they rely on the same evidence. In a two-step reference task, attention at the answer skips the intermediate step because it was resolved earlier in the forward pass: a selector trained on attention achieves 41% accuracy, while the same selector trained on causal evidence reaches 99% and matches the teacher. These evidence sets require no annotation: recovered from a frozen teacher by masking alone, they train selectors to the same accuracy. We find the same conflict in pretrained models: Qwen2.5-3B gives more attention to an outdated fact than the current one on 58% of conflicting-fact examples despite answering correctly, while Gemma-2-9B rises from 56% to 99% accuracy when restricted to the two relevant sentences. Attention shows where a model looks, not necessarily what its answer depends on; across the regimes we tested, that dependence matched or outperformed attention as a training target.
| Comments: | 18 pages, 4 figures, 15 tables |
| Subjects: | Machine Learning (cs.LG); Computation and Language (cs.CL) |
| Cite as: | arXiv:2607.21692 [cs.LG] |
| (or arXiv:2607.21692v1 [cs.LG] for this version) | |
| https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2607.21692
arXiv-issued DOI via DataCite
|
Full-text links:
Access Paper:
- View PDF
- HTML (experimental)
- TeX Source
View a PDF of the paper titled Learning What Matters: Supervising Sparse Attention Routing with Causal Evidence Sets, by Jim Allchin
Ancillary-file links:
Ancillary files (details):
- learning-what-matters/LICENSE
- learning-what-matters/README.md
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/LICENSE
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/README.md
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/analysis/make_appendix.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/analysis/make_figures.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/analysis/make_main_tables.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/LICENSE
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/__init__.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/activation_taps.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/adamw.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/checkpoint.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/cross_entropy_loss.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/data_loading.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/decode.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/delta_rule_attention.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/delta_rule_block.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/delta_rule_lm.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/dfa.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/dfa_sampling.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/embedding.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/gradient_clipping.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/learning_rate_scheduler.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/linear.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/llm.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/looped_transformer_lm.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/lstm_lm.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/mlp_lm.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/multihead_self_attention.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/multihead_self_attention_with_rope.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/rmsnorm.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/rotary_positional_embedding.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/scaled_dot_product_attention.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/sgd.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/softmax.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/swiglu.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/tokenizer.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/train_bpe.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/training_plots.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/transformer_block.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/blocksmith_lm/transformer_lm.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/__init__.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/ablation.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/agreement.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/attention.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/harness.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/labels.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/pretrained.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/routers.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/tasks.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/tasks_hard.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/learning_what_matters/vocab.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/pyproject.toml
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/rebuild_all.sh
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/reproduce.sh
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/agreement/base/report.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/agreement/base5/report.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/agreement/extended/report.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/agreement/greedy_chains.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/chain_hard_causal.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/chain_hard_imitation.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/chain_router_grid.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/chain_router_imitation.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/chain_router_transfer.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/hardened_dense_baselines.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/multihop_router.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/oracle_routing.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/recovered_synth.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/recovered_synth_budget.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/recovered_synth_delta.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/recovered_synth_floor.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/recovered_synth_gradient.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/recovered_synth_hybrid.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/recovered_synth_verified.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/recovery_rules.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/diagnostics/router_bench.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/Qwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/Qwen2.5-1.5B-Instruct.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/Qwen2.5-14B-Instruct.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/Yi-1.5-9B-Chat.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/gemma-2-9b-it.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/overwrite_Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/overwrite_Yi-1.5-9B-Chat.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/overwrite_gemma-2-9b-it.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/real_qa.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/real_qa_typematched.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/routing_Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/routing_Qwen2.5-7B-Instruct.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/routing_Yi-1.5-9B-Chat.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/routing_gemma-2-9b-it.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/routing_recovered_Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/scaling_recovered_128.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/scaling_recovered_32.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/pretrained/scaling_recovered_64.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/routers/ablation/results.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/routers/base/results.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/routers/base5/results.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/routers/base_3x/results.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/routers/base_lr3e3/results.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/routers/base_lr3e4/results.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/routers/extended/results.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed0/anchors.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed0/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed0/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed1/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed1/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed2/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed2/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed3/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed3/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed4/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/base/seed4/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed0/budget_curve.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed0/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed0/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed1/budget_curve.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed1/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed1/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed2/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed2/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed3/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed3/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed4/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/extended/seed4/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/hardened/seed0/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/hardened/seed0/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/hardened/seed1/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/hardened/seed1/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/lp_lr1e3/seed0/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/lp_lr1e3/seed0/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/lp_lr1e4/seed0/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/lp_lr1e4/seed0/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/smoke/seed0/config.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/runs/teachers/smoke/seed0/metrics.json
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/agreement_report.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/analyze_recovery.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/anchors.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/bench_router.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/budget_curve.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/diag_aggregation.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/diag_ar.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/diag_multihop.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/greedy_chains.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/hardened_dense.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/oracle_routing.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/overwrite_intervention.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/pretrained_probe.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/pretrained_recovered.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/pretrained_router.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/real_qa.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/train_chain_router.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/train_recovered_synth.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/train_routers.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/scripts/train_teachers.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/tests/test_ablation.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/tests/test_attention.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/tests/test_labels.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/tests/test_routers.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/tests/test_tasks.py
- learning-what-matters/learning-what-matters/tests/test_tasks_hard.py
- learning-what-matters/requirements.txt
References & Citations
Loading...
Bookmark
Bibliographic Tools
Code, Data, Media
Demos
Related Papers
About arXivLabs
Bibliographic and Citation Tools
Bibliographic Explorer Toggle
Bibliographic Explorer (What is the Explorer?)
Connected Papers Toggle
Connected Papers (What is Connected Papers?)
Litmaps Toggle
Litmaps (What is Litmaps?)
scite.ai Toggle
scite Smart Citations (What are Smart Citations?)
Code, Data and Media Associated with this Article
alphaXiv Toggle
alphaXiv (What is alphaXiv?)
Links to Code Toggle
CatalyzeX Code Finder for Papers (What is CatalyzeX?)
DagsHub Toggle
DagsHub (What is DagsHub?)
GotitPub Toggle
Gotit.pub (What is GotitPub?)
Huggingface Toggle
Hugging Face (What is Huggingface?)
ScienceCast Toggle
ScienceCast (What is ScienceCast?)
Demos
Replicate Toggle
Replicate (What is Replicate?)
Spaces Toggle
Hugging Face Spaces (What is Spaces?)
Spaces Toggle
TXYZ.AI (What is TXYZ.AI?)
Recommenders and Search Tools
Link to Influence Flower
Influence Flower (What are Influence Flowers?)
Core recommender toggle
CORE Recommender (What is CORE?)
IArxiv recommender toggle
IArxiv Recommender
(What is IArxiv?)
arXivLabs: experimental projects with community collaborators
arXivLabs is a framework that allows collaborators to develop and share new arXiv features directly on our website.
Both individuals and organizations that work with arXivLabs have embraced and accepted our values of openness, community, excellence, and user data privacy. arXiv is committed to these values and only works with partners that adhere to them.
Have an idea for a project that will add value for arXiv's community? Learn more about arXivLabs.
More from arXiv — Machine Learning
-
LoKiFormer: Locality-aware Attention with Decoupled Knowledge Memory for Efficient Large Language Model Pretraining
Aug 14
-
Which Site, and When: A Free-Satellite-Data Test of Himalayan Glacial Lake Bursts, Landslides, and Ice Floods
Aug 14
-
MARCH: Scaling Recurrent Memory with Content-Routed State Anchors
Aug 14
-
Multi-AUV Ad-hoc network-based Target Tracking: A Value Gradient Guidance Multi-Agent Diffusion Reinforcement Learning Approach
Aug 14
Discussion (0)
Sign in to join the discussion. Free account, 30 seconds — email code or GitHub.
Sign in →No comments yet. Sign in and be the first to say something.