Playing One Night Werewolf (Gemma4 & Qwen3.6)

Finally feel like it’s possible. I have a custom build (vibe coded) UI on llama.cpp, allows model switching in the same chat. So I thought I’d get Gemma4 31B Q4, Gemma4 26B Q5, Qwen3.6 27B Q5, Qwen3.6 35B Q4 all together to play ONUW.

Had to switch the thinking off the Qwens so they don’t think out loud into public chat.

So firstly at night I assigned each llm with a card (werewolf, seer, villager, troublemaker) and the read their card.md, and write their observations and thinkings in their own Mr as to keep it private to each. Then day time in the game I bring them to public game chat. Each turn they read their md, defend and ask questions, record their observations for 8-10 turns, then write their final thought down for voting. Back to individual chat for voting.

Gemma4 31B — best lier. Clearest thoughts in notes. Gemma4 26B — suck at using tools. Quick to think but no deep thoughts. Qwen3.6 35B — thought it was villager and tried to be bold. Got owned. Best at tool calls. Qwen3.6 27B — not very bright when thinking is off. Oh so slow …

Not a very productive way of using llms I know…Any models I can add to the game ? Suggestions?